Some of the sportsbooks featured on this page are our partners. We may receive compensation if you sign up for one through our links, but this doesn't affect our ratings or opinions in any way. You can learn more by visiting our advertiser disclosure page.
If you’re trying to decide on which sportsbook to go with, you may be considering BetMGM Sportsbook and Barstool Sportsbook. Both of these sportsbooks are legal and licensed in U.S. states but have unique offerings.
Our BetMGM vs. Barstool sportsbook comparison will help you decide which is better for your sports betting needs.
To start, we rated BetMGM Sportsbook as 5 out of 5 stars and Barstool Sportsbook as 4.1 stars. This means if you’re just looking for the best overall sportsbook, then BetMGM is a better option than Barstool in our opinion.
Ratings
States
Intro Promo
Sports Offered
Bet Types
Deposits
Withdrawals
Customer Support
BetMGM vs. Barstool Sportsbook State Availability
BetMGM State Availability & Rankings
- Arizona (#1 of 9 AZ Sportsbooks)
- Colorado (#1 of 12 CO Sportsbooks) (See the BetMGM CO bonus code)
- Illinois (#1 of 7 IL Sportsbooks) (See the BetMGM IL bonus code)
- Indiana (#1 of 10 IN Sportsbooks)
- Iowa (#1 of 10 IA Sportsbooks) (See the BetMGM IA bonus code)
- Kansas (#1 of 6 KS Sportsbooks)
- Louisiana (#1 of 7 LA Sportsbooks) (See the BetMGM LA bonus code)
- Maryland (#1 of 7 MD Sportsbooks)
- Massachusetts (#1 of 7 MA Sportsbooks)
- Michigan (#1 of 10 MI Sportsbooks) (See the BetMGM MI bonus code)
- Nevada (#1 of 3 NV Sportsbooks)
- New Jersey (#1 of 16 NJ Sportsbooks) (See the BetMGM NJ bonus code)
- New York (#1 of 7 NY Sportsbooks) (See the BetMGM NY bonus code)
- Ohio (#1 of 9 OH Sportsbooks)
- Pennsylvania (#1 of 12 PA Sportsbooks)
- Tennessee (#1 of 6 TN Sportsbooks) (see the BetMGM TN bonus code)
- West Virginia (#1 of 7 WV Sportsbooks)
- Wyoming (#1 of 3 WY Sportsbooks) (see the BetMGM WY bonus code)
- Virginia (#1 of 12 VA Sportsbooks)
Barstool Sportsbook State Availability & Rankings
- Arizona (#8 of 9 AZ Sportsbooks)
- Colorado (#9 of 12 CO Sportsbooks)
- Illinois (#7 of 7 IL Sportsbooks)
- Indiana (#9 of 10 IN Sportsbooks)
- Iowa (#8 of 10 IA Sportsbooks)
- Kansas (#6 of 6 KS Sportsbooks)
- Louisiana (#7 of 7 LA Sportsbooks)
- Maryland (#7 of 7 MD Sportsbooks)
- Massachusetts (#7 of 7 MA Sportsbooks)
- Michigan (#8 of 10 MI Sportsbooks)
- New Jersey (#9 of 16 NJ Sportsbooks)
- Ohio (#8 of 9 OH Sportsbooks)
- Pennsylvania (#9 of 12 PA Sportsbooks)
- Tennessee (#6 of 6 TN Sportsbooks)
- Virginia (#9 of 12 VA Sportsbooks)
- West Virginia (#6 of 7 WV Sportsbooks)
BetMGM Sportsbook vs. Barstool Sportsbook Intro Promo
When it comes to the intro promo for new customers, we rated BetMGM Sportsbook as 4.5 stars and Barstool Sportsbook as 4.5 stars.
BetMGM Sportsbook offers a $1,000 risk-free bet that is refunded as multiple bets. You have 7 days to use the credit and there is a 1x playthrough requirement.
Barstool Sportsbook offers a $1,000 risk-free bet that is refunded as site credit. You have 30 days to use the credit and there is a 1x playthrough requirement.
BetMGM Sportsbook vs. Barstool Sportsbook Odds Competitiveness
When it comes to the competitiveness of odds, we rated BetMGM as 5 out of 5 and Barstool as 2 out of 5.
To come up with these ratings, we analyzed hundreds of games in all major sports and leagues to find which books, on average, give customers the best deals.
If you’re looking for the most competitive odds, overall, then BetMGM is a better option than Barstool according to our data.
BetMGM Sportsbook vs. Barstool Sportsbook Promotions & Odds Boosts
When it comes to ongoing promotions and odds boosts that all customers can take advantage of, we rated BetMGM Sportsbook as 5 stars and Barstool Sportsbook as 5 stars.
BetMGM and Barstool are pretty much equal according to our data.
Odds boosts and promotions vary from sport to sport, so check with each to see which offers better specials on the sports you care about the most.
BetMGM Sportsbook vs. Barstool Sportsbook User Interface
We rated the BetMGM Sportsbook user interface as 5 stars, or ‘Best' and Barstool Sportsbook as 5 stars, or ‘Best'.
While most legitimate online sportsbooks in the U.S. are similarly designed and are easy enough to navigate, there are small things here and there that can make using one much more enjoyable than the other.
Before registering, it may be worth downloading both apps or visiting their websites to see which you like better.
Here are some images of BetMGM Sportsbook (click to expand):
And here are some images of Barstool Sportsbook (click to expand):
BetMGM Sportsbook vs. Barstool Sportsbook Bet Types
Almost all major sportsbooks offer all of the main types of sports bets, including spreads, totals, moneyline bets, parlays, teasers, props, and futures, as well as live betting and cashing out of bets early.
One thing that not all offer, however, is same game parlays which allow you to combine sides, totals, and props from one game into a single parlay.
As of this writing, BetMGM and Barstool both offer same game parlays.
BetMGM Sportsbook vs. Barstool Sportsbook Deposits & Withdrawals
Having a variety of methods to deposit money into your account and to transfer your money out of it is another important thing when it comes to finding the best sportsbook.
We rated BetMGM Sportsbook's banking options as 5 and Barstool Sportsbook's as 4 stars.
BetMGM Sportsbook offers 7 deposit methods and the minimum deposit amount is $10. It also has 7 withdrawal methods and the minimum withdrawal is $20.
Barstool Sportsbook offers 8 deposit methods and the minimum deposit amount is $10. It also has 5 withdrawal methods and the minimum withdrawal is $1 – $250.
Bottom Line on if BetMGM Sportsbook or Barstool Sportsbook is Better
While our overall rating shows that BetMGM is a better option than Barstool, it’s important to think about what you value the most when it comes to sports betting.
Use the comparison tool above to directly compare the things that are most valuable to you and check out our full reviews to learn more about all of the things we briefly touched on in this article.
And remember, there is really no limit to the number of sportsbooks you can sign up for. Actually, it’s always a good idea to have at least a few that you can bet with so you can shop around for the best lines and odds, and so you can take advantage of the promotions that each offers.
You can also check out our full BetMGM Sportsbook Review and Barstool Sportsbook Review to learn more about each option.
*Special offers from our partners. May vary by state.
Our Partners
Intro Bonus
Next Steps
No Sweat First Bet Up to $1,000
States: AZ, CO, CT, IL, IN, IA, KS, LA, MA MD, MI, NJ, OH, NY, PA, TN, WV, WY, VA
Second Chance Bet Up to $500
States: AZ, CO, IL, IN, IA, LA, MD, MI, NJ, NY, OH, PA, VA
Up to $1,000 Back in Bonus Bets
States: AZ, CO, IL, IN, IA, KS, LA, MA, MD, MI, NJ, NY, OH, PA, TN, VA, WV, WY
100% Deposit Match Up to $100
*Not a sportsbook. DFS site that offers Pick'Em contests on player stats.
