Dabble vs. Underdog

Dabble vs. Underdog State Availability – Winner: Underdog

Underdog currently spreads its wings wider than Dabble. It operates in 40 states across the U.S., which is twice as many as Dabble.

Here's where each is available:

Dabble State Availability

• Alaska
• California
• District of Columbia
• Florida
• Georgia
• Illinois
• Kansas
• Kentucky
• Minnesota
• New Mexico
• North Carolina
• North Dakota
• Oklahoma
• Oregon
• Rhode Island
• South Carolina
• South Dakota
• Texas
• Utah
• Wisconsin

Underdog State Availability

• Alabama
• Alaska
• Arizona (College Pick’em unavailable)
• Arkansas (College Pick’em unavailable)
• California
• Colorado (Pick’em games must contain 4 selections)
• Florida
• Georgia
• Illinois
• Indiana (College Pick’em unavailable)
• Kansas
• Kentucky
• Maine (College Pick’em unavailable)
• Maryland (no Pick’em games)
• Massachusetts (College Pick’em unavailable)
• Minnesota
• Mississippi (College Pick’em unavailable)
• Missouri (no Pick’em games)
• Nebraska
• New Hampshire (no Pick’em games)
• New Jersey (no Pick’em games)
• New Mexico
• New York (College Pick’em unavailable)
• North Carolina
• North Dakota
• Ohio (no Pick’em games)
• Oklahoma
• Oregon
• Pennsylvania (no Pick’em games)
• Rhode Island
• South Carolina
• South Dakota
• Tennessee (no Pick’em games)
• Texas
• Utah
• Vermont (College Pick’em unavailable)
• Virginia
• West Virginia (no Pick’em games)
• Wisconsin

Dabble vs. Underdog Sign-Up Bonus – Winner: Underdog

Underdog wins this round by having a larger welcome bonus.

New players at Underdog can claim a 100% deposit match up to $100 after signing up. Use promo code ODDS100 to get this offer.

Newcomers at Dabble are handed out $10 in free entries with promo code ODDS—no deposit required.

Both welcome bonuses come with a 1x playthrough requirement, meaning you need to play the bonus funds at least once before you can withdraw any winnings.

What sets these bonuses apart, besides their size, is the time you've got to use them. Underdog gives you a leisurely 60 days to make the most of your bonus. Dabble, though, puts a tighter deadline on theirs—you've got 14 days to use it or lose it.

While Underdog gives more total value, Dabble's welcome offer doesn't require you to deposit any funds, meaning you can try out the platform with no financial commitment.

Dabble vs. Underdog Incentives for Returning Players – Winner: Dabble

Dabble offers more incentives for returning players than Underdog.

Underdog gives its players some nice bonuses, like profit boosts for certain Pick’em games. Imagine hitting all your picks and seeing your winnings jump from 20x to 60x. They also offer $10 in site credit for every friend you bring in.

Dabble offers even more for its regulars. Think rocket boosts and a wheel promo that gives you more rewards the more you play. And just like Underdog, you get $10 for every friend who signs up with your code. Dabble also runs freerolls, which are missing at Underdog.

Neither has a loyalty program, but Dabble really makes it worth your while to stick around.

Dabble vs. Underdog Pick’em Payouts – Winner: Underdog

Both apps offer the same payout rates for 2, 3, 4, and 5 pick entries without insurance but Underdog offers better payouts than Dabble for Pick’em entries with insurance.

While Underdog limits you to 5 picks per entry, Dabble allows you to string together as many as 12 picks, with the chance of a 1,000x payout if you nail all 12.

While this is a plus for Dabble, it's not a game-changer since those longshot entries are really hard to hit.

Check out our guide to payouts across all Pick’em DFS platforms to see how Dabble and Underdog stack up.

Dabble vs. Underdog User Interface – Winner: Dabble

For the user interface, I've got to give it to Dabble. Something about how it's set up just works better for me than Underdog. But honestly, both apps are pretty great at making things user-friendly.

While their layouts share similarities, some key differences set them apart.

Dabble organizes its sports right at the top, guiding you to games, followed by athletes listed vertically. For each athlete, there are dropdowns for specific stats, making it easy to see your options for each one.

Underdog takes a different approach. You select a sport, but then it shows you players along with various stat lines all on one card—so for someone like Mahomes, you'd see options for passing TDs, passing yards, and interceptions all together in one spot.

Both methods work well, but I have a slight preference for Dabble's layout—it's a bit more intuitive to me.

Underdog's desktop layout is all about smooth navigation. When you choose a game, the player options are immediately visible, and your betting slip appears neatly on the right. It's a one-page wonder that lets you jump into your picks without skipping a beat.

On the other hand, Dabble is still working on launching its desktop version, so there's a bit of waiting to see how it stacks up.

Dabble vs. Underdog Contest Variety – Winner: Underdog

In contest variety, Underdog outshines Dabble by offering a wider range of options.

At Dabble, Pick'em contests are the sole focus. Participants craft their entries by predicting whether athletes will surpass or not reach specific statistical lines.

For example, you could choose whether Nikola Jokic will have more or less than 7.5 assists, or if Jalen Hurts will have more or less than 275.5 passing yards.

Dabble provides two gameplay modes: All In and Hedge. In All In, every one of your choices needs to be correct to win. Hedge, on the other hand, acts as a safety net, offering a smaller prize if some of your picks don't hit.

Underdog, too, has Pick’em games but refers to its version of Hedge as Insurance. Everything else about how it works is pretty much the same as Dabble's contests.

Beyond the usual Pick’em format, Underdog adds a unique spin with their “rivals” matchups. In these contests, you're tasked with predicting head-to-head outcomes, such as deciding if Nikola Jokic will score more points than Joel Embiid.

Adding to the mix, Underdog also runs draft-based contests, including daily drafts and season-long Best Ball. You select a team through a draft and then earn points based on how those players perform in real life.

For Best Ball, the goal is to accumulate enough points to advance through rounds, aiming for a share of the prize pool.

A key highlight of Best Ball is its set-it-and-forget-it nature. Once the season kicks off, your lineup is locked in. Underdog automatically picks your best-performing players for the week.

Some of Underdog's Best Ball tournaments boast prize pools of up to $10 million, with first place sometimes walking away with $2 million.

Dabble vs. Underdog Sports Coverage – Winner: Tie

Both platforms cover 9+ sports markets. However, the specific sports available on each platform do vary a bit.

At Dabble, you can make entries across these sports:

• NBA
• NFL
• MLB
• NHL
• NCAAB
• NCAAF
• Golf
• Soccer
• MMA

Meanwhile, Underdog swaps out college sports for a few others, including:

• NBA
• NFL
• MLB
• NHL
• Boxing/MMA
• Soccer
• Formula 1
• Tennis
• Golf
• Esports

Choosing a favorite in sports coverage really comes down to your personal favorites since both platforms serve up a great but slightly different mix.

Dabble vs. Underdog Banking – Winner: Underdog

Banking options are somewhat limited on both platforms, offering just a few choices for deposits and withdrawals. Here’s what you can expect.

Dabble's deposit methods include:

• Credit/debit card (Visa, Mastercard)
• ApplePay

Underdog's deposit methods include:

• Credit/debit card (Visa, Discover, Mastercard, Amex)
• PayPal

Your choice might depend on which payment method you prefer.

If you use Mastercard or Amex and don't have Apple Pay, Underdog is your only option.

Furthermore, PayPal users might lean towards Underdog, while ApplePay fans would likely gravitate to Dabble.

Dabble also has a more accessible entry point, requiring only a $5 minimum deposit, compared to Underdog's $10.

As for payouts, Dabble is generally quicker, often processing withdrawals within 1 to 5 days, and typically in just 24 to 72 hours, making it a slightly faster option for accessing your winnings.

Learn more in our full guides:

• Underdog Fantasy Deposits & Withdrawals | Payout Times
• Dabble Deposits & Withdrawals | Payout Times

Dabble vs. Underdog Final Verdict – Tie, Both Platforms Are Great

After testing out both Dabble and Underdog, it's tough to declare a clear favorite. Choosing comes down to your personal preference and what you're looking for in a DFS app.

Each platform has its unique take on contest rules, promotions, banking methods, and sports coverage, so your decision could rest on which aspects you value more.

This comparison is just a snapshot of what Dabble and Underdog have to offer. For a deeper dive into each, be sure to check out my Dabble review and Underdog review.

Signing up for both is also a sound strategy. This way, you get to enjoy the best of both worlds. Grab those sign-up bonuses, play around on each to get a feel for them, and compare player stat projections on each app before placing any entry to make sure you're getting the best deal.

Here are some other guides we have on Underdog and Dabble:

• Dabble vs. PrizePicks
• Underdog vs. PrizePicks 
• Underdog vs. Sleeper
• Underdog Alternatives
• Best DFS Sites