Underdog vs. PrizePicks – Which DFS Site is Best?

Companies featured on this page may be our partners who compensate us if you sign up for one through our links. This doesn't affect our ratings or opinions in any way. Must be 21+. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. See full disclosure.

PrizePicks vs. Underdog has become a major debate among DFS fans. Both platforms have surged to the top of the daily fantasy sports (DFS) market with their popular Pick'em games.

While many are torn on which one takes the crown, there are key differences that can help you decide which is best for you.

PrizePicks is centered around its Pick’em games, where users predict whether players will go higher or lower on certain statistics, such as rushing yards or points scored. With PrizePicks, you're up against the house, not other players.

Underdog offers Pick’em games, season-long Best Ball, and the more traditional draft-based contests that can stretch over a week or the entire season. With Underdog, you can play against the house (Pick’em) or against other players (Best Ball and other drafts).

There are pros to both platforms. By registering on both, not only do you get to experience their unique offerings, but you can claim the sign-up bonuses. Their offers are currently the same, with both offering a 100% deposit match up to $100.

In the PrizePicks vs. Underdog showdown, Underdog pulls ahead in aspects like user experience, mobile app functionality, diversity of contests, platform availability, and notably, higher payouts for 3-pick and 4-pick entries.

On the other hand, PrizePicks offers a wider sports selection for Pick’em games, more banking options, better perks for regular users, bigger payouts for 5-pick and 6-pick entries, and live chat support—something Underdog misses out on.

All in all, we've found that Underdog and PrizePicks are about the same according to our analysis. We recommend using both since each has better payouts for different types of entries.

Underdog vs. PrizePicks Overview

	Underdog Fantasy	PrizePicks
Odds Assist Rating	5.0	5.0
Payouts	Bigger payouts for 3 & 4-pick entries	Bigger payouts for 5 & offers 6-pick entries
Welcome bonus	100% match deposit up to $100	100% deposit match up to $100
Promo code	ODDS100	ODDS100
Available in	40 states	32 states + DC
Sports covered	9+ markets	31+ markets
Contests	Pick’em, Best Ball, drafts	Pick’em
Minimum deposit	$10	$10
Mobile app	iOS & Android	iOS & Android
Customer Support	Email, phone	Email, live chat

PrizePicks vs. Underdog State Availability – Winner: Underdog

Underdog covers more ground than PrizePicks. They're up and running in 40 states, while PrizePicks is available in 32 states and DC.

Check out the full rundown of states for each DFS platform below.

Underdog State Availability

Alabama
Alaska
Arizona (College Pick’em unavailable)
Arkansas (College Pick’em unavailable)
California
Colorado (Pick’em games must contain 4 selections)
Florida
Georgia
Illinois
Indiana (College Pick’em unavailable)
Kansas
Kentucky
Maine (College Pick’em unavailable)
Maryland (no Pick’em games)
Massachusetts (College Pick’em unavailable)
Minnesota
Mississippi (College Pick’em unavailable)
Missouri (no Pick’em games)
Nebraska
New Hampshire (no Pick’em games)
New Jersey (no Pick’em games)
New Mexico
New York (College Pick’em unavailable)
North Carolina
North Dakota
Ohio (no Pick’em games)
Oklahoma
Oregon
Pennsylvania (no Pick’em games)
Rhode Island
South Carolina
South Dakota
Tennessee (no Pick’em games)
Texas
Utah
Vermont (College Pick’em unavailable)
Virginia
West Virginia (no Pick’em games)
Wisconsin

PrizePicks State Availability

Alabama (Pick'Em Arena only)
Arkansas
Arizona
California
Colorado (Free to Play only)
District of Columbia
Georgia
Illinois
Indiana
Kansas
Kentucky
Massachusetts (Pick'Em Arena only)
Michigan (Free to Play only)
Minnesota
North Carolina
North Dakota
Nebraska
New Mexico
New York (Free to Play only)
Oklahoma
Oregon
Rhode Island
South Carolina
South Dakota
Tennessee (Pick'Em Arena only)
Texas
Utah
Virginia
Vermont
Wisconsin
West Virginia (Pick'Em Arena only)
Wyoming (Pick'Em Arena only)

PrizePicks vs. Underdog Sign-Up Bonus – Winner: Tie

PrizePicks and Underdog have identical welcome bonuses. Both are handing out 100% deposit matches up to $100. To claim either bonus, just type in ODDS100 when registering.

Here's where they match up again: both platforms have a minimum deposit of $10 and share a user-friendly 1x wagering requirement. This means that you can pull out whatever you win from those entries or keep playing.

Now, for the slight difference: PrizePicks allows a 90-day stretch to use the bonus, while Underdog gives you a 60-day run. Either way, both timelines offer plenty of opportunity to put those bonus funds to work.

PrizePicks vs. Underdog Incentives for Returning Players – Winner: PrizePicks

Underdog offers a few perks for existing customers, namely specials and payout boosts for their Pick’em games. For example, a 5-pick entry might see its payout tripled. So, instead of the standard 20x, you could be looking at a 60x payout if you nail 5/5 on Higher/Lower. They also run a referral bonus, granting $10 in site credit for each friend you bring on board.

PrizePicks has a larger assortment of ongoing promos. You might stumble upon random cash drops they call “Airdrop,” score some discounts giving you a better line on a stat, enjoy payout boosts, or even get a safety net with protected play—where a losing entry gets you a refund in bonus credits. They also run a refer-a-friend deal.

Neither DFS platform runs a loyalty/VIP program.

PrizePicks vs. Underdog Pick’em Payouts – Winner: Tie

When you stack up PrizePicks and Underdog, their payouts on Pick’em games are in the same ballpark, with just a few differences based on how many picks you're playing with. It's all about how you like to play and how many picks you feel confident about.

Underdog has the edge for 3-pick and 4-pick entries. They offer 3x and 6x payouts for hitting 3/3 and 4/4, respectively. In contrast, PrizePicks gives 2.25x and 5x payouts for those same entries.

PrizePicks pulls ahead when it comes to 5-pick entries with a 22x payout for a clean 5/5, while Underdog offers 20x. Additionally, PrizePicks has an option for 6-pick entries, something Underdog doesn't provide as they cap at 5 picks.

You can learn more in our guide to payouts on DFS Pick’em games. It lays out payouts for all Pick’em game providers by entry size.

PrizePicks vs. Underdog User Interface – Winner: Underdog

Underdog's DFS platform stands out with its sleek presentation. The site is well-designed, and the execution is user-friendly. You'll find the main buttons neatly lined up horizontally, and there's a handy search bar in the Pick’em lobby to simplify navigation.

The platform's desktop design is seamless. Choose a game, and the players appear front and center, with the slip conveniently showing up on the right. Everything is on one screen, so you can dive right in without any fuss.

On mobile, the design is adapted for compact screens. When you select a game, the players dominate the view, and the slip smoothly slides down from the top, occupying just the right amount of space, making navigation intuitive and efficient.

Both DFS platforms lean into darker themes. However, Underdog's combination of yellow and dark hues is particularly easy on the eyes.

On desktop, PrizePicks has a different layout than Underdog. Instead of a left-side sports list, they've positioned them horizontally. When you pick a game, the related options are displayed just below the sports lineup.

One hiccup with PrizePicks is that on their desktop site, there's a chunk of unused space in the board section. It feels a bit empty. On the flip side, their mobile app stands out for its user-friendliness. The inclusion of subsections for each stat category streamlines browsing.

Both platforms deliver in terms of performance. They're responsive and don't let you down in the stability department.

Here are some screenshots of the PrizePicks app (click to expand):

And here are some screenshots of the Underdog app (click to expand):

PrizePicks vs. Underdog Contest Variety – Winner: Underdog

PrizePicks is all about Pick’em games. In these contests, you're up against the house, trying to guess if an athlete will surpass or fall short of a given stat line or fantasy points (which account for various performance metrics).

Players have two gameplay options: power and flex. In the power mode, you need all your picks to be correct for a payout. The flex mode offers a bit more leeway; you can earn a smaller payout even if some picks are off. Notably, PrizePicks pioneered the insurance feature in Pick’em games, rolling it out in 2019.

PrizePicks offers a contest called Pick'em Arena in five states, where, much like their usual offerings, you pick between 2 to 4 stats for athletes and decide if they'll exceed or fall short. Your picks are pooled with those of players who made similar choices at similar times and have similar skill levels. The goal is to nail all your picks for a perfect score or outdo everyone else in your group to take the win. Victorious players can bag up to 10 times what they put in, and if you're the top scorer with a flawless lineup, the full prize pot is yours.

Underdog boasts a broader variety of contests. While they offer the same Pick’em games as PrizePicks, they also have head-to-head matchups, termed “rivals”. In these, you predict if one athlete will outperform another, such as deciding if Nikola Jokic will score more than Joel Embiid.

Underdog also throws in draft-based contests known as Best Ball. Here, you craft a team from a player draft and earn points from their real-world performances. Those racking up the most points move through the rounds, with the top performers grabbing a slice of the prize pool.

One great thing about Best Ball is that when the season starts, you're set. There is no need to tweak your lineup as Underdog takes the best players on your roster for that week. The prize pools can be massive. They've had tournaments with a whopping $10 million prize pool, where the top spot took home $2 million.

PrizePicks vs. Underdog Sports Coverage – Winner: PrizePicks

Both PrizePicks and Underdog have great sports coverage, featuring 9+ markets. At Underdog, the lineup includes:

NBA
NFL
MLB
NHL
Boxing/MMA
Soccer
Formula 1
Tennis
Golf
Esports

This roster captures most of the mainstream sports markets in the U.S. However, PrizePicks takes the lead with its inclusion of niche sports.

Alongside all of Underdog's offerings, they also feature cricket, NASCAR, WNBA, trucks, lacrosse, Korean baseball, frisbee golf, and some offbeat specials like competitive eating (think hot dog eating contests).

PrizePicks vs. Underdog Banking – Winner: PrizePicks

When it comes to banking, PrizePicks has more options than Underdog. Here's the breakdown:

PrizePicks Deposit Methods:

Visa/Discover credit or debit card
Instant Bank Transfer
PayPal
ApplePay

Underdog Deposit Methods:

Visa/Discover/Mastercard/Amex
PayPal

PrizePicks has the edge with instant bank transfers and ApplePay.

Both platforms set their minimum deposit and withdrawal at $10. However, it's worth noting that PrizePicks requires you to play through your deposit once (a 1x wagering requirement) before you can cash out.

PrizePicks Withdrawal Options:

Bank transfer
PayPal
Debit cards

Underdog Withdrawal Options:

PayPal
Bank transfers
Prepaid cards
Physical checks

Regardless of your choice, expect a withdrawal processing time of 1-5 days, depending on the method, at both sites.

Learn more in our full guides:

PrizePicks vs. Underdog Final Verdict – Winner: Underdog Comes Out Slightly on Top

When weighing everything, Underdog slightly outpaces PrizePicks in overall quality, though they run closely in most categories.

The deciding factors? It boils down to what games you're into, the look and feel you prefer, and how you like to play (like how many picks you want in your entries). These distinctions set the two platforms apart.

This article is here to help you decide which platform aligns more with your tastes. For a deeper dive, our PrizePicks review and Underdog Fantasy review break down each aspect of the comparison.

A practical approach might be to register with both platforms. This allows flexibility to switch based on your mood or the situation, and you can take advantage of their promotions along the way.

Want to compare Underdog or PrizePicks to other DFS apps? Check out these guides: